Can Decentralized Stablecoins Stabilize?
Decentralized finance (DeFi) idealists want to create perfectly free financial ecosystems that can’t be subverted by governments, corporations or regulators. They also want their decentralized nirvana to be equipped with stablecoins so users can be protected from price craziness.
Therein lies the contradiction.
J.P. Koning, a CoinDesk columnist, worked as an equity researcher at a Canadian brokerage firm and a financial writer at a large Canadian bank. He runs the popular Moneyness blog.
Are decentralized anarchic systems, those that have no link to existing centralized institutions, capable of creating stability? Or are they too unanchored to generate the traction necessary for a stablecoin to be, well, stable?
A new wave of stablecoin architects thinks it’s possible. They want to create money that is not only stable but also avoids relying on the authorities that underpin the dollar system.
Whether these new experiments work is another question.
USD coin domination
Before I describe what these new experiments are, let me show what problem they are trying to solve.
DeFi refers to a set of financial applications built on blockchains using smart contracts, unstoppable and transparent bits of computer code. The biggest DeFi community is on the Ethereum blockchain, but other competing blockchains such as Binance Smart Chain, Terra and Tron are also trying to nurture a DeFi ecosystem.
A stable money is important to people who participate in financial transactions. Volatile assets like bitcoin and ethereum don’t cut it. The Ethereum DeFi ecosystem’s thirst for stability has led it to become hugely reliant on USD coin, a U.S. dollar stablecoin issued by the Centre Consortium, consisting of Coinbase and Circle.
J.P. Koning – Regulation Could Actually Help Tether
USD coins are rock solid, but only because they are backed by dollars held in Circle’s accounts at a regulated bank. That bank is, in turn, connected to what most DeFi “maximalists” would probably see as the triple-headed snake of centralization: the Federal Reserve, America’s central bank; the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, which regulates and insures banks; and FinCEN, the U.S.’s anti-money laundering watchdog.
So, ironically, DeFi’s success, which rests in part on its stable tokens, comes courtesy of good ol’-fashioned Wall Street database technology.
The decentralization idealists worry that Circle, the issuer of USD coin, might be required to freeze addresses at the behest of law enforcement. FinCEN may require it to carry out know your customer (KYC) checks, thus unveiling a huge swath of DeFi. None of this is compatible with a purely decentralized financial nirvana.
Which gets us to some of the solutions that are being proposed.
No-collateral or collateral-lite
The most radical stablecoin experiments are empty set dollar, dynamic set dollar and basis cash. This trio of stablecoins, deployed on the Ethereum blockchain, tries to achieve decentralization by doing away with collateral.
Collateral refers to the “backing” assets that traditional money issuers have always relied on to ensure the stability of the money they issue.
In place of collateral, all three stablecoins deploy incentives that encourage stablecoins owners to refrain from selling whenever the stablecoin falls below $1. As more stray stablecoins are temporarily locked away, the supply of stablecoins gets reduced. In theory, this should push the stablecoin’s price back up to $1.
THEIR PRICES AS OF YESTERDAY WERE $0.13, $0.16 AND $0.28 RESPECTIVELY, FAR BELOW THEIR $1 TARGET PRICE.
No-collateral money is a breakthrough idea for decentralization maximalists. Collateral, especially when it is regulated, is one avenue by which a stablecoin can be “subverted.” That’s why basis cash, one of the no-collateral experiments, advertises itself as “without regulatory risk.”
But there’s a problem with empty set dollar, dynamic set dollar and basis cash. Their prices as of yesterday were $0.13, $0.16 and $0.28 respectively, far below their $1 target price. These experiments don’t seem to be working out.
One no-collateral stablecoin does appear to be functioning, however: terraUSD. Found on the Terra blockchain, terraUSD is currently ranked the fifth-largest stablecoin on CoinGecko.
Like empty set dollar and its close relatives, terraUSD’s stability relies on incentives, not collateral. When terraUSD falls below $1, say to 98 cents, traders are given an opportunity to buy terraUSD and quickly convert them into $1 worth of newly created LUNA tokens, the Terra blockchain’s governance token. And so traders earn a 2-cent profit. This has the effect of sucking up the excess supply of terraUSD and bringing it back to $1.
See also: J.P. Koning – What Happens if All Stablecoin Users Have to Be Identified?
Another stablecoin experiment, frax, has adopted a less radical collateral-lite framework. To maintain its $1 price, frax uses a similar incentive mechanism to terraUSD. But the frax protocol also holds a layer of collateral in reserve. The 110 million frax stablecoins currently in circulation are anchored by $96 million reserves, the remaining $14 million being unbacked.
Like terraUSD, frax has succeeded in maintaining a $1 price over the last few months.
So for decentralization maximalists who want stable money without collateral, it’s a mixed bag. Experiments like empty set dollar have stalled. But others appear to be working, at least for now.
Black swans
No-collateral and collateral-lite stablecoins are often advertised as technological advances. If so, one wonders why traditional finance never evolved its own versions of no-collateral money, despite centuries of lead time.
One possibility is no-collateral money isn’t sustainable in the long term. The biggest threat to any stable asset is a “black swan” market disruption. People panic. There’s a run from riskier stable assets into less-risky ones. Pegs, once rock solid, melt away.
In response to these disruptions, a centuries-old blueprint for establishing stable money has evolved: over-collateralization. That is, if a bank issues $10,000 in fresh dollar IOUs to a home buyer, that $10,000 will be more than covered by the value of the borrower’s house and downpayment.
Alternatively, if a bank lends to an investor and takes, say, Tesla shares as security, it will require $150 worth of Tesla for each dollar lent. The $50 is a “haircut” that the bank uses to protect itself.
As long as a banker is careful to apply appropriate haircuts, then when a panic hits and pressure builds on the bank’s $1 peg the bank can always sell this collateral and use the funds to support its peg.
[THEY] MAY NOT BE ABLE TO WEATHER A MAJOR BLACK SWAN EVENT, SAY LIKE A MARKET CRASH.
For instance, even if the value of Tesla collateral collapses from $150 to $100, the bank will still have enough “backing” to support the money it has issued.
The worry is that in dispensing with collateral as a line of defense (or using less of it), the new breed of less-than-fully collateralized stablecoins may not be able to weather a major black swan event, say like a market crash, an outbreak of war or a new pandemic.
It’s possible that less-than-fully collateralized stablecoins will prove to be an enduring advance in financial technology. If so, they’ll imbue DeFi with true stability while simultaneously disconnecting it from the incumbent financial system.
Or they could be highly risky assets that offer only the illusion of safety. We’ll know which it is when the next big market disruption hits.
Recommended News
-
What is the origin of the capitalist FTS that has set the NFT market alight?
The world’s progress is a process of subversion and re-subversion, innovation and re-innovation, however, every epoch-making technological revolution has fundamentally advanced the progress of human civilization,, with Bitcoin’s ten-year 26 million investment income, and created numerous wealth myths in just a few years, the emergence of Bitcoin has also made the decentralized distributed ledger blockchain technology popular worldwide , making Bitcoin gradually The fourth industrial revolution, with blockchain as its core, will bring unprecedented changes to humanity. NFT (TNon-Fungible Token), a digital cryptocurrency on the blockchain, is divided into…
-
Bear Market Shocks! CoinW’s 0 transaction fee on spot trading helps users to make valuable investment
Fears of a global recession and the worst inflation in over 40 years have wreaked havoc on the emerging cryptocurrency market this year. Coming into August, the crypto industry shows no signs of recovery. It is not easy for investors to stay calm, but it is important to remember that regardless of market conditions, never be an ostrich with your head in the sand, but rather follow the laws of the market and make the most of the current bear market opportunities to find investment breakthroughs. Total cryptocurrency market cap…
-
LibraSwap cross-chain transaction to lead the Swap 2.0 wave
LibraSwap is the first NFT, cross-chain exchange platform where you can mint (create) NFTS through a crypto chain and easily exchange tokens between crypto chains. LibraSwap’s mission is to provide consumers with cryptocurrency-based financial services that enable them to exchange or “exchange” various digital assets. LibraSwap is committed to providing consumers with cryptocurrency-based financial services that enable them to exchange or “exchange” various digital assets. To facilitate cross-chain Dex and cross-chain exchange between ETH and BNB for exchange settlement that exceeds the limits of a typical isolated blockchain network. …
-
Since ONP launched the liquidity mining policy on January 21, 2021,
Since ONP launched the liquidity mining policy on January 21, 2021, the 48-hour-accumulated liquidity-pool pledge volume has exceeded USD 1,000,000. According to the latest news, the entire aggregated decentralized oracle network – ONP (Oracle Network Protocol) has kicked off the liquidity mining policy upon Uniswap Exchange on January 21, 2021. And the total 48-hour accumulated liquidity pool has been more than USD 1,000,000. ONP (OracleNetworkProtocol) is an aggregated decentralized oracle network based on the theories of Chainlink and Bandprotocol, which can realize safe, smooth and high-efficiency information-data interconnections between block-chain and the reality, as well…
-
If Bitcoin Starts Closing Below the 50-Day SMA It May Mean Deeper Pullback Ahead
Bitcoin fell sharply on Sunday, dipping well below the 50-day simple moving average (SMA) support for the first time in six months. While the decline looks typical of a bull market correction, it could be extended further if prices find acceptance under the 50-day SMA, according to one analyst. “The loss of [bullish] momentum is only short-term in nature, but we would view consecutive closes below the 50-day SMA as a reason to move to the sidelines,” Katie Stockton, technical analyst and managing partner of Fairlead Strategies, told CoinDesk in…
-
Staking as an Asset Class? This Swiss Institutional Fund Is Jumping In
While institutional investors around the world are just getting their heads around bitcoin (BTC, -1.43%), asset managers in crypto-friendly Switzerland are heading into staking on next-generation blockchain networks. Announced Friday, Zurich-based investment firm Tavis Digital has partnered with Singapore-based Persistence, a bridge for traditional firms into undiscovered realms such as token staking and decentralized finance (DeFi). Tavis Digital is a spin-off of Tavis Capital, an asset manager regulated by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) with about $1.07 billion in assets under management. Nimble and financially sophisticated countries like Switzerland and…
-
CoinW pioneer’s the strides of world-class comprehensive crypto capital venture, as the EAFF E-1 Championship concludes.
After 9 days and 12 matches, the EAFF E-1 Championship 2022 officially came to an end on the 27th, with a total of male and female soccer players from China, Korea, Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. The offiical supporter of EAFF E-1 Championship 2022, CoinW, cheers for the participating football players. After 12 matches, the host, Japan, won the 2022 East Asian Cup men’s and women’s football championships, the Chinese women’s football team won the second prize, and the Chinese men’s football team, composed of young players, won the third…
-
Singapore Twin Towers Joint Foundation to Create STO Digital Age
First Growth Funds (ASX:FGF) and Singapore City Investment and Development Foundation jointly funded the establishment of Singapore Twin Towers Joint Fund. Currently, the co-management scale of the fund has reached 2 billion US dollars. The main investment areas are financial asset flow, new infrastructure, digital securities ecological construction. Digital new technology research and development and other cutting-edge digital fields. On Singapore’s joint towers foundation based on digital reform by STO, cutting-edge technology can assign the traditional entity enterprise and global popular areas, investment in developing countries for technology, capital,…
-
Blockchain+ energy, IEA is born strong
The rapid growth of the earth’s population and the industrialization of developing countries are pushing global energy demand to unprecedented levels. The world’s energy dependence on fossil fuels such as coal, oil, and natural gas poses a major risk to the environment and is one of the main factors causing adverse climate change. With these challenges, new approaches to energy production and distribution are needed. The solution must support dynamic and sustainable global growth, for which the IEA came into being. The IEA Foundation was established by the Japanese IEA…
-
The Vision of Ethanim: Building New Public Chain for the Metaverse
As the advanced version of the digital era, many metaverse applications using multiple digital technologies are approaching us. Blockchain technology makes digital identity unique and digital asset confirmation also becomes possible. It builds a trustworthy economic form and also accelerates the development of metaverse. In the past six months or so, the metaverse conceptual application represented by crypto games has been noticed. Traditional game developers have introduced digital assets and NFT based on blockchain technology into the game precisely to form a new metaverse conceptual game with unified value and…
